The Sit, Down, Come, Heel, Stay and Stand Book, by Claire Arrowsmith (Tfh Publications, $17.95, 28pp, 2008) Review by Skye Anderson
As a scientist I tell my students not to refer to papers written more than five years ago. As a dog trainer I tell my clients not to depend on everything in a book more than five years old. So, what did we here at DogEvals do? Review a book more than five years old!
I had gone through this book quite a while back and really liked it. Then I took another look at it - today. I still like much of it and will recommend it with some caveats.
The Good
There is a lot to like in The Sit . . . book. A hard cover over a spiral bound book so it lies flat! Each of the six basic behaviors in the title and in the book is covered on facing pages with several steps devoted to how to get the behavior (The Basics). Also included on the two pages are the hand signal, what to do if your dog just doesn't get it (troubleshooting, Overcoming Problems), TIPS, and modifications for smaller dogs. Demo dogs are big and small. Other topics are covered for some of the behaviors and topic names differ.
I like the cardboard pages: this book is meant to be used!
A fold-out achievement chart with steps for each behavior can be torn out from the book. The steps are grouped in threes with award stickers for each three as they are achieved.
A two-page introduction and on the other side of the achievement chart are pages of helpful hints such as using toys instead of treats as a reward, using and fading treat rewards, treat pouches, timing and three golden rules.
The Bad
The pages are not numbered though the book does have a table of contents.
The Ugly
Nothing
There are slight differences between how the author trains and how I train and she may have gradually come over to how I do things as the years have passed but these are minor issues and I would either point them out to a client or simply ignore the differences. For example, the author rewards the dog with a treat plus the phrase, Good Dog, upon completion of a behavior while I would omit the words for a while and then use a one-syllable word.